Malvern police went to check for Ferguson at his home on Miner Street. When they arrived they spotted a bullet hole in a window and called county detectives. Searching the garage apartment, Detective Gary Lynch spotted other bullet holes in the walls, as well as blood on the floor and a spent .380 cartridge. He discovered Ferguson's lifeless body buried under a bean bag chair and other debris. Searching for Dudas after speaking with Ferguson's grandmother, detectives went to Caroselli's family home, where Dudas lived in a basement room. They spotted Ferguson's Honda outside, and found Dudas and Caroselli in a second-floor bedroom. Dudas has been sentenced to 20 to 40 years after pleading guilty to killing a former friend and hiding his body in a sleeping bag last fall.